Robert Manwill—Is God to Blame?
Webcast: October 20, 2009
For 10 excruciating days this summer, our community prayed and held out hope for “the little boy with the mischievous grin.” Eight-year-old Robert Manwill went missing in late July touching off one of the largest searches in Boise’s history.
The discovery of the missing boy’s body in a Kuna canal was like a punch in the gut felt by the entire community. The tragedy hit the volunteer searchers particularly hard. For one such volunteer, the pain was personal.
“The day they found Robert’s body floating in that canal I crumpled to the ground and just sobbed. I knew right where those canals were. I swam in those very same canals when I was a child. I was truly devastated. I never gave up for one minute that Robert would be brought home. . . . As a parent my heart was ripped out. I was hurt, angry, and disgusted.”
Hurt. Anger. Disgust. Emotions appropriate for such a crime. But who’s to blame? Some would point to the Robert Manwill case as proof that a loving God does not exist, or, if he does, he’s either evil or impotent. How do people of faith reconcile an all-powerful, all-loving God with the earthquakes, tsunamis, terrorist attacks, wars, child abductions and murders that plague our existence without rhyme or reason?
As one who struggles and hurts like everyone else, here are a few of my thoughts.
God did not create evil, but He did create choice. God presented the human family with the choice to stay in loving fellowship with Himself or to choose independence. God is the source of all life and happiness. Separation from the Source of life brings death. Our first parents chose independence from God—a choice that brought sin and suffering into the world. (See Genesis 3.)
An all-loving God didn’t create evil, but He takes responsibility for it. As soon as sin entered the world, the Creator accepted responsibility and made Himself the bridge that sinners could cross to find their way back to life.
“Which is easier,” Jesus said, “to say, ‘Your sins are forgiven, or to say, ‘Get up and walk’?” (Luke 5:23). To provide a temporary miracle of healing took just a word; to provide the permanent miracle of grace to forgive the sins of humanity took His life.
Does God weep for Robert Manwill? Yes, as He does for the millions of others who suffer in our broken world. But the cross proves that He does more than weep. He also saves. And because He’s not willing that any perish (2 Peter 3:9), the search for all God’s “lost” children continues.
Posted: October 20th, 2009 under Blogs.
Comments: none